Let me get this out-of-the-way now, I’m disappointed with this one. I haven’t loved every recipe from the book but generally have been successful technically at making the recipes. Not so for this loaf. I’m not sure where I went wrong exactly, maybe I shouldn’t have used the proofing feature of my oven to warm up the dough after its overnight stay in the Fridge? Or maybe I put too much flour in the dough trying to get it to form a ball.
All I know is that I now have three albeit good tasting bricks sitting on my counter and I’m not sure what to do with them. I’ll try toasting some throughout the week but still alone to eat of three it’ll be a chore. I’ll try freezing them but usually that just means that I’ll forget them there and still end up throwing them out. Though by then the disappointment is not so fresh.
If I was to try this again, I would skip the over night and do a second proof directly after the first one. I also might try putting a lot less flour in as well. But I said if, a quickbread version of this would be less trouble and just as tasty I’m sure.
Cranberry Walnut Pumpkin Loaf on page 108 is being hosted by Rebecca at This Bountiful Backyard


Even if it didn’t turn out well, your blog was interesting, entertaining, and helpful! I think you were successful. Kristine Mika of louisawalter
Sorry they didn’t turn out! Especially after all that time! Hope it’s better next time!
I’m so sorry this didn’t turn out–baking is not an exact science for sure. We enjoyed these loaves but I’m baking some pumpkin quick bread with chocolate chips–tomorrow!
Well, even if it didn’t turn out the way that you wanted it, it looks beautiful and is the perfect fall bread.
I do the same! I have a hard time tossing something out so in the fridge it goes and gets tossed after it has spoiled. Easier that way. I have not like much of the recipes either, but keep on baking hoping the next will be better.